Showing 1–9 of 15 results
“Our Famous” Longhorn CheddarShop Now
Longhorn cheddar is a customer favorite. We manufacture this cheese just like the good old days, by wrapping our smooth cheddar in cheesecloth and dipping it in wax to preserve freshness.
Cheddar CurdsShop Now
The freshest part of cheddar, Cheddar Curds are a fan favorite from Watonga Cheese Factory. Our Cheddar Curds still contain a small amount of moisture, which creates their signature squeak that has become so popular.
Mild CheddarShop Now
A Watonga Cheese Factory tradition, this rich mild cheddar established the quality that defines us. In fact, we still follow the original 70-year-old recipe with each batch that is manufactured.
Sharp CheddarShop Now
Lovers of our famous Mild Cheddar will be thrilled with our Sharp Cheddar cheese. Additional aging produces a cheddar that is tangier with more complex and deeper flavors.
White CheddarShop Now
Our famous Mild Cheddar made better! No ordinary white cheese, our White Cheddar Cheese contains no additional color additives to retains its natural creamy color, texture, and flavor.
Bacon CheddarShop Now
Packed with the flavor combo everyone loves, our Bacon Cheddar tastes great melted on a burger or tossed in a salad. Whether you love cheese or bacon, our Bacon Cheddar will quickly become your favorite.
Cheddar PepperShop Now
When you’re in the mood for a little extra kick, satisfy it with our Watonga Cheddar Pepper. One of our popular products for those who love heat, Watonga Cheddar Pepper is made with only the freshest jalapenos.
Habanero CheddarShop Now
The latest flavor in our family of cheddars, Habanero Cheddar may soon become your new favorite snack. We used just the right amount of habanero peppers to give true spice lovers what they crave.
Onion CheddarShop Now
The addition of fresh green onions mixed into our smooth cheddar makes an unforgettable experience. Using the ideal amount of fresh green onions, this cheese is perfect for baked potatoes, Mexican dishes and burgers.